Librarëtte Little Stories · 080 · Kingston, Jamaica · Ages 7–11
The Secret Recipe Club had four members, one rulebook, and a single problem that nobody would talk about in front of Grandma Ivy.
The rulebook was written on the back of a calendar. Our club president, Rochelle, wrote the rules in capital letters with a purple marker:
RULE ONE: We make Grandma Ivy's sweet potato pudding. RULE TWO: We do not tell Grandma Ivy we are making it. RULE THREE: Nobody touches the oven except Rochelle. RULE FOUR: Nobody eats the pudding before it is done, even if it looks done.
"Who wrote rule four?" asked my cousin Bunny, who was seven and had already eaten a spoonful of raw sugar.
"I did," said Rochelle. "Because you ate the last one."
I am Jaden, and I was the one who brought the pudding to the club, in a way. Grandma Ivy had made it every Sunday for as long as I could remember. She made it in a deep blue pot, with grated sweet potato, coconut milk, brown sugar, and a sprinkle of spice that smelled like Christmas in a teacup. When it came out of the oven, it was golden at the edges and so soft it wobbled when you put a spoon in it.
And for as long as I could remember, Grandma Ivy had said the same thing when people asked her how she made it.
"One ingredient," she said, "I will never tell you."
The club began on a rainy Saturday, when the four of us were stuck in Grandma's kitchen because the power had gone out and the streets were flooded up to the gutters.
We were Rochelle, who was eleven and bossy; Tami, ten, who cared about colour and cake; Bunny, who was seven and fast; and me, Jaden, who was twelve and had been told he could help as long as he didn't touch the knives.
Grandma Ivy was in the living room with her radio. We had a lantern, a bag of sweet potatoes, a tin of condensed milk, and a plan.
"We have to figure out the last ingredient," said Rochelle, tapping the calendar. "We know what's in it. We've watched her make it a hundred times. But there's always something she puts in at the very end, and then she covers the pot with the lid so we can't see."
"It's the nutmeg," said Tami. "I'm sure of it."
"It's not nutmeg," said Rochelle. "She puts nutmeg in at the start."
"It's sugar," said Jaden. "Brown sugar, burnt a little."
"You don't know anything," said Bunny cheerfully.
We made four puddings that day, all of them terrible.
The first one was too sweet. Tami had added an extra tin of condensed milk because she thought more sweetness meant more love. The second had too much coconut. The third one burned on the bottom.
The fourth pudding was not bad. It was just not right. It did not wobble, and it did not smell like Christmas.
"We're missing something," said Rochelle. "Something she never says out loud."
We were quiet for a while. The rain kept falling. Through the wall, Grandma Ivy was singing very badly and laughing at herself.
"Maybe," said Bunny, "she just puts in a secret."
"Everyone puts in a secret," I said. "That's not the point."
"No," said Rochelle, slowly. "The point is that she doesn't say it. She never tells anyone. So how did she learn it?"
We went looking for answers.
We looked in the cupboards and the fridge. We found six jars of spice, a bag of allspice that had gone hard, and a single lime leaf wrapped in a cloth, as if someone had been keeping it warm.
Then we went out into the back yard, where the air smelled of wet earth and jasmine. There was a big old thyme plant beside the back step, spilling over its clay pot.
Bunny crouched beside the thyme plant. "Hey," he said. "Grandma talks to this one."
"She talks to all the plants," I said.
"No," said Bunny, very seriously. "She says good morning to this one, and then she pinches off one little sprig, and she puts it in the pudding, and she says a word under her breath. Every time."
We looked at each other. We looked at the thyme. Then Rochelle pulled out her notebook and wrote, in purple capitals: CHECK THE THYME.
That night, we came back to the kitchen with a plan. We would make one more pudding, this time with the thyme in it. But we would also tell Grandma Ivy everything, because we had been keeping secrets from her for almost a whole week, and that felt wrong.
Grandma Ivy listened to us, sitting on her kitchen stool with a cup of cocoa tea in both hands. She did not interrupt once. When we had finished explaining about the rulebook, the purple marker, the four terrible puddings, and the thyme, she was quiet for a long time.
Then she laughed. It was the big, warm, full laugh that filled the whole house.
"Children," she said. "Children, children. Do you think I would hide the ingredient from you?"
"You said you would never tell us," said Tami.
"I said I would never tell you," Grandma said, "because you would never believe me."
She got up, went to the back step, and picked a single sprig of thyme from the clay pot, the one that Bunny had been watching.
"My mother gave me this plant when I got married," she said. "She told me, every good thing in a kitchen needs something you cannot buy. So I say good morning to it, and I pinch off one sprig, and I put it in my pudding, and I say, thank you for growing with me. Every time."
"That's the secret?" asked Bunny.
"That's the secret," said Grandma. "The thyme. And the thank you. You can't measure either one. You just have to mean it."
We made the pudding the next Sunday, in the big blue pot, with Grandma Ivy beside us. Rochelle did the oven. Tami measured the sugar and only added one tin of condensed milk. Bunny stirred. I grated the sweet potato.
And before the lid went on, Grandma took a single sprig of thyme and dropped it into the pot, and we all said, together, under our breath, "Thank you."
When the pudding came out of the oven, it was golden at the edges and soft enough to wobble. It smelled like Christmas in a teacup. When we took our first spoonfuls, nobody spoke for a full minute.
Then Bunny said, with his mouth full, "Okay. Rule four is cancelled."
Rochelle crossed out the rule in purple marker. Under it, she wrote a new one, in capitals that were very slightly wobbly.
RULE FIVE: Everything tastes better when someone says thank you.
Grandma Ivy read it over Rochelle's shoulder, and she laughed so hard she had to sit down.
"Now that," she said, wiping her eyes, "is the best ingredient I ever gave away."